Wir nutzen Cookies auf unserer Website. Einige von ihnen sind essenziel, während andere uns helfen diese Website und ihre Erfahrung zu verbessern.

Heft 1-2024

Emperor Julian and his critique of Christianity in Contra Galilaeos

PD Dr. Nikolai Kiel, Alte Geschichte, Universität Frankfurt

In his work Contra Galilaeos, written in the winter of 362, Julian engages in a critique of the spreading of Christianity. At his time, the pagan cult of gods was steadily losing significance, while the Christian movement was gaining increasing appeal. Seeking to avoid a widespread persecution of Christians across the empire, Julian chooses to combat Christianity using the weapons of “Neoplatonic” philosophy. He challenges the central doctrine of Christians, which asserts that Jesus of Nazareth was the incarnate God-Logos. To transcend this concept, Julian proposes three divine savior figures as alternatives to the Christian God. According to him, the three gods who appeared in human form on earth – Asclepius, Heracles, and Dionysus – surpass the Christian narrative of the generation of God-Logos by God the Father and its incarnation on earth. Julian presents them as deities who manifested in bodily form, providing tangible assistance to humanity, and offering redemption in a manner superior to the Christian doctrine.

Aspects of laicization, religious-pedagogical consolidation and dissolution of boundaries of theology in the 15th century using the example of the Dialogus Noviciorum by Thomas à Kempis

Prof. Dr. Ingo Klitzsch, Seminar für Kirchengeschichte II, Ev.-Theol. Fakultät, Universität Münster

The article takes a deliberately ateleological perspective on the 15th century. Using the example of the Devotio moderna, it highlights tense aspects of theological lay emancipation as well as religious-pedagogical concentration and the dissolution of boundaries in theology. The study is based on the small genres Notabilia verba and Exercitia devota, which have been recorded in Thomas à Kempis’ (1379/80–1471) Dialogus Noviciorum. These texts have received less attention in research to date, but are most significant in terms of the reception of this work. The thematic focus is on the propagated attitude towards the world and the “seculars”, the functionalization of a cook as a “teacher” and the conveyed valuations of studies and the acquisition of knowledge.

Johann Peter Miller and the Wertheim Bible

Dr. Hannah M. Kreß, Seminar für Kirchengeschichte II, Ev.-Theol. Fakultät, Universität Münster

Johann Melchior Goeze’s (1717–1786) criticism on Johann Peter Miller’s (1725–1789) short and almost incidental appreciation of the Wertheimer Bibel in 1773 can appear at first sight somehow delayed. By contextualizing it to the criticism Goeze uttered at the same time regarding Carl Friedrich Bahrdt’s (1740–1792) translation of the New Testament, its topical relevance becomes obvious. Moreover, this debate alludes to various controversial and crucial aspects which were argued more broadly in public later during the Fragmentenstreit.

On the origins of the “Mass of Saint Gregory”

Dr. Jan Reitzner, Institut für Spätmittelalter und Reformation, Ev.-Theol. Fakultät, Universität Tübingen

Gregory the Great is said to have seen Christ during the Eucharist. The origins of this vision lead through the Legenda Aurea and the Vita Gregorii of Paulus Diaconus to an anonymous Vita from Whitby. In Whitby, at the time in question, the Verba Seniorum were undoubtedly known as part of the Vitas Patrum. The most famous apophthegm, however, bears striking similarities to the Gregorian vision. Given the structural and literal similarities, the socio-cultural context, and lastly the specific understanding of history and truth in the Vita, this paper argues that a dependence is very likely.

Theological arguments for slavery in the antebellum American South

Prof. Dr. Lydia Schumacher, King’s College London, Department of Theology and Religious Studies

In the years leading up to the American civil war (1861–65), clergy working under the auspices of the main evangelical Protestant denominations, in particular, Presbyterians, Methodists, Anglicans, and Baptists, became some of the main defenders of slavery in the southern United States. This essay explores some of the common arguments they advanced in favour of slavery as well as their responses to some of the counter-arguments that were mounted by anti-slavery thinkers. The goal is to demonstrate how a particular approach to reading the Bible was used to justify a racist outlook that supposedly legitimised the oppression of African Americans.

Heft 2-2024

Children, young people and the First Crusade in Latin crusade chronicles from the first half of the 12th century

Philipp Endmann, Ilshofen

This study examines the mention of children and adolescents during the First Crusade (1096–1101) in Latin Crusade chronicles from the first half of the 12th century. The aim is to elucidate how children and adolescents are presented in this context and what this reveals about their perception. This research contributes to a little deeper understanding of the social, cultural and religious dimensions of the First Crusade, highlighting the often-overlooked roles and perceptions of younger participants.

When does Church History begin?

Dr. Bernhard Holl, Erzbistum Berlin

The theological understanding of “church history” is commonly quite literal – the history of the Christian church from its apostolic beginnings to our present day. This article proposes the somewhat different approach of a Historical Theology encompassing not only the Christian Era but all history of mankind. By highlighting selected concepts from Augustine (ecclesia ab Abel), Marsilio Ficino (prisca theologia) and Simone Weil (images du Christ) it aims to show why the study of different eras from prehistory to secular postmodernism can indeed be relevant and informative for the theological endeavor in general.

The “Oriental Schism”

PD Dr. Christian Lange, Kirchengeschichte, Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg

The so-called Oriental Schism is often associated with the year 1054, when the Roman legate Humbertus of Silva Candida excommunicated the patriarch of Constantinople, Michael Cerularius. However, various arguments suggest that the growing separation between the Latin and Eastern Christian churches was a longer lasting process. On the one hand, the excommunications of the year 1054 related to individuals, but not to the Latin and Greek churches as a whole. For example, in the same year 1054, the Greek patriarch Peter III. of Antioch confirmed ecclesiastical communion with the apostolic see of Rome. On the other hand, in 1054 the Roman side made the systematic theological accusation of a “heresy” against the Patriarch of Constantinople, which is why the events of 1054 meet the early church criteria of a “heresy” rather than a “schism”. In addition, the Latin Crusaders established their own Latin patriarchs in Antioch, Jerusalem and Constantinople, which is why from the end of the 11th century there were two parallel episcopal lines of Greeks and Latins in these cities. Therefore, this paper argues that the so-called Oriental Schism might rather be understood as a longer lasting process, which took its beginning in the 6th century, when (Eastern) Roman Emperor Justinian banned anti-Chalcedonian bishops of Antioch and Alexandria und replaced them with pro-Chalcedonian successors. The process came to an end when Latin crusaders drove the legitimate Greek patriarch of Constantiople out of the city in 1204 and appointed a Latin successor.

Neology in a pragmatic sense

Bastian Lemitz, Seminar für Kirchengeschichte II, Ev.-Theol. Fakultät, Universität Münster

By taking a close look at one of Gottfried Leß’ (1736–1797) sermons being published as a supplement to the third edition of his Sontags-Evangelia (1781) it can be shown that it is more than likely that its physicotheological content has been taken from Von der Güte und Weisheit Gottes in der Natur (1778) written by Heinrich Sander (1754–1782), a nowadays little-known professor of natural history and eloquence at the Gymnasium illustre in Karlsruhe. And although Leß is picking up on Sanders’ physicotheological work on purpose the author argues that Leß can still be considered a notable representative of the so called Neology.

The Catholic Church and the state terrorism in Argentina 1976–1983

PD Dr. Federico Tavelli, Lehrstuhl für Mittlere und Neuere Kirchengeschichte / Frömmigkeitsgeschichte und Kirchliche Landesgeschichte, Universität Freiburg

This article examines the ideological positions of Catholicism, particularly the church authorities in Argentina during the military dictatorship and state terrorism 1976–1983. In the 1960s and 1970s in Latin America, and especially in Argentina, ideologies had a great influence on the increase of violence. Catholicism played an important role during this period. Not only did political ideologies operate in the Church, but some theologies were also the foundation of political ideas. The article examines the ideological tensions within Catholicism and the positions of the Argentine Episcopal Conference, the Holy See, and the Apostolic Nuncio, and shows how these positions are understood in the context of political ideologies and the consequent division of Catholicism into radical positions.

“War and Struggle against Christianity”, Pastor Michael Schmitt’s confrontation with Alfred Rosenberg’s “Myth” in his Sunday sermon on July 18, 1937 in the Würzburg parish church of St. Lawrence

Dr. Tobias Haaf, Bayerisches Staatsministerium für Wissenschaft und Kunst, München

Sermons delivered on Sundays and church holidays were the central instrument used by the clergy in parishes to counter the National Socialist ideology with biblical truths and Catholic beliefs. During the Third Reich, these sermons were therefore closely monitored. Using the example of a sermon by the Würzburg pastor Michael Schmitt from 1937, which led to a charge against him for “abuse of the pulpit” and “treachery”, this essay illustrates the Catholic Church’s confrontation with Alfred Rosenberg, the leading ideologue of the National Socialist movement, and his main work “The Myth of the 20th Century”. In this work, Rosenberg pursued an anti-Semitic and racial theoretical approach, illustrated the alleged superiority of the Nordic race and created a countermodel to “judaized” Christianity of catholic charakter with his “Religion of Blood”. The Holy Office placed Rosenberg’s “Myth” on the List of Prohibited Books in 1934. Catholic clergy such as Michael Schmitt awakened the faithful and rejected Rosenberg’s theses, not primarily because of their anti-Semitic approach, but because of their anti-church thrust.

Heft 3-2024

Theatre as Homiletics

Dr. Christian Bogislav Burandt, Hannover

Hrotsvit von Gandersheim – better known as Roswitha – was the first person after classical antiquity to write theatre plays. She flourished in the imperial monastery of Gandersheim in the period 962–968 AD. She modeled her form and style on the Roman poet Terence, while her content drew on material from the Christian tradition. Her aim was to preach Christianity, as the interpretation of the preface to her Book of Drama shows. The essay shows this in detail using the example of the play “The Resurrection of Drusiana and Calimachus”. The drama is a sermon on the promise of salvation and life in Jesus Christ, which applies to all people, calls sinners to repentance, excludes envy and arrogance and invites them to rejoice and praise God.

Is Nothing Something? Fredegisus of Tours’ Treatise De Substantia Nihili et Tenebrarum between Platonism and Patristics

Dr. Daniel E. D. Müller, Lehrstuhl für Kirchengeschichte des Mittelalters und der Neuzeit, Kath.-Theol. Fakultät, Universität Bochum

Is nothing something, or is it not? – This fundamental question of being was answered around the year 800 by the Carolingian court philosopher Fredegisus of Tours (d. 834), who unequivocally affirmed it: nothing exists, and it is something truly magnificent from which the entire world was created. While contemporaries and later scholarship have, at best, responded to this claim with divided opinions, the present contribution highlights it as a unique interpretative achievement. This is done through an immanent analysis of Fredegisus’ line of argument and a comparative contextualization within the intellectual history of the period. The study shows how Platonic, patristic, and contemporary Frankish influences are independently transformed by Fredegisus, thereby building a conceptual bridge to the Scholastic tradition, which is generally regarded as more philosophically productive.

Et sunt multa quae de iudicio illius homines ignorant 
Eschatological Expectation and correctio from Jerome to Alcuin

Prof. Dr. Emanuele Piazza, Dipartimento di Scienze della Formazione, Università degli Studi di Catania

This paper analyses how the most important early medieval authors perceived and represented the eschatological fears and expectations of their time. In order to do so, it is first necessary to trace the specific events in the sources that were interpreted as omens of the approach of God’s judgment. If the barbarians, with their devastating invasions, were initially seen as a concrete symbol of the imminent end of time, after they had stabilized in their respective regna in Western Europe and had also converted to the Christian faith, new and no less fearsome spiritual enemies, such as sin and heresy, came to the fore, besieging the Church from within rather than from without. Adversaries that tormented the soul and against which Christian writers constantly appealed to the eschatological theme, in particular to an everyday eschatology, in order to urge sinners to correct before time ran out. From the sack of Rome in 410, which the Church Fathers saw as an opportunity to press the faithful to a process of purification and penance that would free them from their sins, to the reign of Charlemagne, tempora periculosa, in which both heretics and new barbarians disturbed the order and peace of the Christian empire created by the Frankish ruler, significant references to the expectation of the dies iudicii can be found in the sources. The end of the world, however plausible or implausible any calculation of the exact moment of its coming might be, was still indefinite on the temporal horizon, and yet it urged the faithful to prepare their souls for the inexorable Judgment of God.

Theodor Berckelmann and Theological education at Helmstedt around 1600 (with an appendix of sources)

Prof.  Dr. Philipp Pilhofer, Institut für Kirchengeschichte, Christliche Archäologie und Kirchliche Kunst, Ev.-Theol. Fakultät, Universität Wien

This paper focuses on the professor of Theology Theodor Berckelmann (1576?–1645) and his “Isagoge” (introduction/guidebook) on how to study Theology. As Berckelmann and his work have hardly been studied to date and as he has always been overshadowed by his colleague Georg Calixt, much fundamental work is still needed. For this reason, his life and work will be examined based on archival sources and then Berckelmann will be situated within the Faculty of Theology in Helmstedt. In the next step, his oeuvre will be discussed. His didactically sophisticated introduction to the study of theology and its origins in his university teaching will be analyzed. The surviving copies of this book are surveyed with regard to ownership marks and traces of usage. The appendix stemming from the archives is intended to facilitate further work.

No Peasants’ War without the Reformation. Johannes Cochläus and his confessional-political struggle against Luther

Dr. Stefan Rhein, Wittenberg

In his fight against the Reformation, the humanist and Catholic controversialist Johannes Cochläus scrutinised Luther’s writings philologically in order to uncover contradictions in or between them and thus expose Luther as an inconsistent theologian. He edited, translated and commented Luther’s statements on the uprising and thus for the first time created the corpus of Luther’s three Peasants’ War writings („Ermahnung zum Frieden“, „Wider die räuberischen Rotten“, „Sendbrief von dem harten Büchlein“), which is still familiar today. Luther’s strategy of blaming Thomas Müntzer for the Peasants’ War was countered by Cochläus with his media campaign, which sought to frame the Peasants’ War as a ‘Luther War’ and discredit the reformer as both the instigator of the revolt and a traitor to the peasants. In addition to his confessional polemics, Cochläus’ concern for the political stability of Germany should not be overlooked.